Changes in The Wesleyan Discipline over the
years
This summer my denomination will have a General Conference. These happen every four years and it is the only time the entire denomination meets in legislative session and can initiate changes in our Discipline—and there are lots of ideas about needed changes, though fewer of the “ideators” will take the time to actually write resolutions. There’s usually far more heat than homework. Since I am in one of The Wesleyan church’s educational institutions I’ve been wondering what our role should be. It is obvious to me what the people in theology and History and Bible should do to serve the discussion—but what about me—I’m in the practical field. So I decided one of my roles is to do homework for busy pastors DSs and General officers to aid in their decision-making process. I’ve already done plenty of homework and posted it (see links at bottom) but over Spring Break another idea came to me.
I wondered how much change we’ve already seen in The Discipline in the last 50 years. So I decided to do the homework. I compared what Wesleyans have said in their Disciplines over the last 50 years. I started with the two denominations that came together to form the Wesleyan church—the Pilgrim Holiness Manual of 1950, and the Wesleyan Methodist Discipline of 1951 to give me a base line from about 50 years ago. Third I took the new Discipline that came 18 years later as a result of Merger in 1968—The Wesleyan Discipline, 1968. Finally I leaped forward 36 years to 2004, the most recent edition of the Wesleyan Discipline, 2004. I really wanted to make some observations I discovered doing this study. But I decided against that—instead I’m just going to post the raw research data and let my readers make the observations. As you study this data, what observations emerge? When you get an insight post it here. (Where I have erred in compiling this please let me know—I did it on spring break in Key West and may have been experiencing Spring fever).
Membership Commitments
Most denominations have a set of rules or promises a church member makes to join the church. In these denominations they were labeled “rules” for a long time until the post-1960’s culture got a better idea and we now call them “Membership Commitments.” The more modern label has less compulsion and enables the church to discipline people for breaking your promise rather than “not keeping our rules.”
Topic |
Pilgrim Holiness, 1950 Church Covenant (30) & Special Rules (63-83) “We promise by the
aid of the Holy Ghost:” |
Wesleyan Methodist, 1951 General Rules (43-49) & Special Rules
(50-60) GENERAL RULES Expected of all; if a member fails we will
admonish them and “bear with them for a season” but if “he repent not he hath
no more place among us.” (47) SPECIAL RULES: The
General Conference requests all pastors & people to carry out and enforce
these rules:” (50) |
Wesleyan, 1968 General Rules (130-132) GENERAL RULES : If any among us do not observe them and habitually
break any of them we will admonish him with charity and bear with him for a
season but if he repent not he shall have no more place among us. (132) |
Wesleyan, 2004 Membership Commitments (260) These are matters of
“collective Christian conscience” guided by the Holy Spirit and are the
historic, ethical and practical standards of The Wesleyan Church. It is expected that those entering into Covenant Membership
shall follow carefully and conscientiously these guides and helps to holy
living. Disregard of the principles embraced in these Covenant Membership
Commitments subjects a member to Church discipline . |
Walk in holiness and
goodness |
To shun sin & walk in
holiness (30.2) |
Doing no harm and avoiding
evil of every kind… (46) doing good to all men
“trampling under foot the doctrine ‘we are not to do good unless our hearts
be free to do it.’” Doing good especially to Christians giving preference to them in
employment and in doing business with them. (47) |
|
|
Church attendance |
To attend church (30.3) |
Attending the public
worship of God, he ministry of the Word, the Lord’s
Supper. (47) |
Attend all the means of
grace such as worship, ministry of the word, the Supper of our Lord, family
and private prayer, fasting or abstinence. (131:13) |
To reverence the name of
God and to honor the Lord’s Day by divine worship and spiritual edification,
participating in those activities which contribute
to the moral and spiritual purposes of this day. (260.1) To grow in the
knowledge, love and grace of God by participating in public worship, the
ministry of the Word of God, the Lord’s Supper, family and personal devotions
and fasting. (260.8) |
Relationships |
Build up the saints, walk
in love, aid each other, courtesy in speech. (30.4);
avoid all “tattling, backbiting, evil-speaking” & “frivolous
conversation”(30.9) |
Avoiding
fighting, quarreling, brawling, going to court against a brother. Avoiding the “using of many words
in buying or selling.” Avoiding uncharitable or unprofitable
conversation;(46) |
Mutually edify others, walk
together in fellowship, give and receive admonition, pray for others, aid
those sick and in distress, cultivate Christian sympathy. (131:7) |
To work together for the advancement of God’s
kingdom and for the mutual edification of fellow believers in holiness,
knowledge and love; to walk together in Christian fellowship by giving and
receiving counsel with gentleness and affection; by praying for each other;
by helping each other in sickness and distress; and by demonstrating love,
purity and courtesy to all. (260.7) |
Giving |
Give cheerfully to church
& missions & the poor. (30.5) “The pastor should instruct the people
to remember their first financial duty is to their home church.” (68) All
members tithe their income into the local treasury with the needs of the
pastor receiving first
consideration. (69) |
Avoiding
“softness or needless self-indulgence” or “laying up treasurers on earth. (46) Give food to the hungry, cloth the naked and
visit those sick or in prison. (47) |
“make
wise use of our material resources ever mindful of our obligation to Christ’s
church and the needs of our fellow men exercising string self-discipline in
personal indulgences demonstrating Christian liberality toward those in
distress thus laying up treasures in heaven.” (131:10) ” |
To exercise faithful stewardship through the wise use of their time
and material resources, practicing careful self-discipline in order to
further the mission of Christ’s church (remembering the principle of tithing
which is basic to the New Testament standard of stewardship) and to
demonstrate compassion to those in need. (260.3) To do
good as much as is possible to all people as God gives opportunity,
especially to those in the body of Christ; by giving food to the hungry, by
clothing the destitute, by visiting or helping those who are sick or in
prison; by instructing, correcting or encouraging them in love. (260.10) |
Devotions |
Maintain family &
secret devotions (30.6) |
Have family and private
prayer. (47) |
[Practice]family
and private prayer. (131:13) |
To grow
in the knowledge, love and grace of God by…family and personal devotions and
fasting. (260.8) |
Family |
Lead our children to Christ
& give them a “guarded Christian Education.” (30.7) |
|
Honor Christ in every phase
of family life, encourage nurture and education of our children so as to bring them early to a saving knowledge of Jesus
Christ and encouraging their Christian education. (131:11) |
To preserve the sanctity of the home by honoring
Christ in every phase of family life and by demonstrating Christlike
love (always avoiding spousal or child abuse), and by living peacefully with
one another, thereby encouraging the nurture and education of the children in
the Christian faith so as to bring them early to the saving knowledge of
Christ. (260.6) |
Debts |
Be just and discharge debts
faithfully. (30.8) |
Avoiding
borrowing money or buying goods without the probability of paying. (46) |
Be just and faithful in all
transactions and commitments fulfilling all contract obligations.” (131:5) |
To live honestly, be just
in all dealings and faithful in all commitments. (260.12) |
Tobacco, alcohol, drugs |
Abstain from sale and use
in all forms, (30.10) |
Avoid drunkenness or the
buying and selling of beverage alcohol or aiding
others to do so. 3(46) Total
abstinence from all intoxicating liquors is the duty of all Christians; the
law should outlaw alcohol as a beverage and it is wrong for the State to tax
or derive revenue from it for it is unscriptural and sinful in principle and
ought to be opposed by every Christian and patriot, furthermore Christians
should vote against this evil and refuse to be controlled by any political
party managed in the interest of the drink traffic.” (58) The use
of tobacco is a great evil and a waste of money and we require our
members to refrain from its cultivation, manufacture sale and use of it in all
forms.(59) We will not receive into membership those who defy this rule
unless they were received into membership before June 28, 1927. [a
grandfather clause dated at the addition of this rule] (60). |
“Abstain from the
manufacture, sale and use of alcoholic beverages and all harmful drugs;”
(131:2) abstain from the cultivation, manufacture, sale and use of tobacco.”
(131:3) |
…abstaining from using or trafficking (production,
sale or purchase)* in any substances destructive to their physical, mental
and spiritual health, such as alcoholic beverages, tobacco and drugs (other
than proper medical purposes of drugs); (260.4) NOTE ADDED: While no “thing” of itself is sinful, the
Christian should avoid the use of anything which
would not help build the fellowship of the church, would not help the
believers to realize their full potential in Christ, or which would enslave
them. In the light of the scientific
knowledge of our day concerning the actual and potential harm of these
substances, total abstinence is more in keeping with these biblical
principles than is moderation. (260.4) *See 6805 265;4 in Appendix
B. where the General Superintendents are widely seen as interpreting this to
allow a member who is an employee but not an owner to participate in such
sales or transporting products. |
Worldly amusements |
Avoid
dances, shows, theaters, horse races, promiscuous bathing (mixed sex
swimming), places
where gambling happens. (30.11) “Inter-church sponsored athletics are
prohibited. (78) |
Avoid the “taking of such
diversions as can not be used in the name of the Lord Jesus.” Singing songs
or reading books which ‘do not tend to the knowledge or love of God.” (46) |
Careful use
of our time “engaging only in such activites that may contribute to our
spiritual, moral, intellectual and physical well-being.” (131:9) |
[see special directions] |
Secret societies &
other organizations |
Shun membership in all
oath-bound societies (30.12) Opposed to membership in any organization of
“labor or capital” involving Christians in unholy alliances. (75) |
Will not
tolerate ministers and members holding fellowship with secret societies. (57) |
Abstain form membership in
secret societies which are oath-bound; “These
prohibitions do not apply to labor, civic or other organizations that do not
contradict loyalty to Christ. (131:12) |
Refraining from membership
in secret societies and lodges which are oath bound, (260.4) These prohibitions do not restrict membership in
labor, civic or other organizations which do not contradict loyalty to Christ
and the Church. When in these relationships Christian principles are violated, members shall be dealt with because of such
violations and not because of the membership itself. |
Dress |
Modestly
according to 1 Peter 3:3-4 & 1 Tim 2:9-10 (passages mentioning “plaiting
the hair, wearing gold, expensive dress, & pearls.” (30.13) “Girls and women are not to appear in
public in immodest dress such as “sun suits, shorts, anklets and no
stockings, dresses of immodest length, slacks or similar garments. Men and
boys should not appear in public in shorts or without shirts.” (64) Since our church has traditional
against the wearing of wedding rings the General Conference of 1950 goes on
record as opposed to the wearing of all rings. (77) |
Avoiding
the putting on of gold or costly apparel or immodest dress. (46) “Let none be received into
the church until they have left off wearing of gold, superfluous adornments,
or have adopted modest attire” (51) Let every member dress with plainness,
economy in light of thousands suffering in the world.” (52, 53) Specified
garb for women as mission workers as “dark blue dress and bonnet with white
ties” once appointed by the conference. (54); Disapprove
changing apparel for funerals and ‘the extravagant waste of money for funeral
displays.” (55); refraining from wearing jewelry as
a testimony (56). |
Dress to adorn the gospel
in the spirit of 1 Peter 3:34 and I Timothy 2:9-10 in purity and modesty,
refraining from superfluous adornment.” (131:8) |
[see special directions] |
Sunday |
Avoiding worldly business
on Sunday such a buying and selling, traveling, pleasures not done with an eye
single to God’s glory. (30.14) |
Avoid doing ordinary work,
or buying or selling. (46) |
“Observe the Lord’s Day by
worship… “avoid all unnecessary commerce, travels,
pleasures which do not contribute to the ends of the day.” (131:1) |
To… honor the Lord’s Day by divine
worship and spiritual edification, participating in those activities
which contribute to the moral and spiritual purposes of this day.
(260.1) |
Cursing |
|
Avoiding
taking the name of God in vain.
(46) |
“Reverence the name of
Deity.” (131: 1) |
To
reverence the name of God.
(260.1) |
Slavery |
|
Avoid the buying or selling
of people with the intention of enslaving them, or holding slaves, or
claiming it is right to do so. (46) |
|
|
Divorce |
No divorced person or one married
to a divorced person can be elected as a leader in a church (64) |
|
We regard adultery as the
only justifiable cause for divorce and in this case the innocent party may
marry again but the guilty party has by their act forfeited
membership in the church. In the case of divorce for other causes
neither part shall be permitted to marry again during the lifetime of the
other and violation of this shall result in expulsion from the church. (131:) |
To follow the teachings of the Scriptures regarding
marriage and divorce. We affirm
that sexual relationships outside of marriage and sexual relationships
between persons of the same sex are immoral and sinful. We further affirm
that heterosexual monogamy is God’s plan for marriage, and we regard sexual
sin of the spouse, such as adultery, homosexual behavior, bestiality or
incest, as the only biblical grounds for considering divorce,
and then only when appropriate counseling has failed to restore the
relationship. (260.5) |
Racism, sexism |
|
|
Respect the inherent rights
of all persons regardless of race, color or sex.” (131:4) |
To respect the inherent individual rights of all
persons, regardless of race, color or sex. (260.11) |
Authority |
|
|
“To respect all duly constituted
authority in the home, the church and the state except when to do so violates
the clear teaching of Scripture.” (131:6) |
|
Leadership |
All leaders should be known for their piety and their careful keeping of
the church covenant; hey should not be vain in attire, in too much debt, or
be boastful, haughty, overbearing. No one who is divorced or married to a
divorced person or living with someone before marriage can
be elected to church office. (63, 64) |
|
|
|
Gambling |
|
|
|
To demonstrate a positive social witness by
abstaining from all forms of gambling (260.4) |
Tongues |
|
|
|
The |
Spiritism |
|
|
|
To
seek only the leading of the Holy Spirit and to abstain from all forms of spiritism, such as the occult, witchcraft, astrology and
other similar practices. (260.2) |
Special Directions
Most denominations have two lists using various names, these denominations often used “Special Directions” or “national reform” as the titles. At the beginning this list was often a place for “social statements” to the church regarding social issues in the world—like prohibition or blue laws. However since the “rules” (now Membership commitments) are binding and members are asked to promise to live in submission to those them, this “special directions” list often becomes a repository for the binding rules that the church still wants to “admonish members about but does not want to use as in-or-out criteria. The first list is constitutional—to change it requires an elaborate constitutional revision process including going back to districts and even to other general conferences in the world. This second list “Special Directions” is statutory and can thus be changed by simple majority vote of any general conference.
|
Pilgrim Holiness, 1950 Special Rules (63-83) Lifestyle “Special
Rules” are included in this table with the Church Covenant above, the reform
rules are listed here. |
Wesleyan Methodist, 1951 National reform (390-394) Expected that all
members will use their influence to favor these positions.” |
Wesleyan, 1968 Special Directions (186-198) Christians ought
to manifest social concern for the transformation of society as a testimony. |
Wesleyan, 2004 The special directions are not required as
promises of members but “are official admonitions to the members, ministers
and officials of The Wesleyan Church” in order to “provide guidelines” for a
testimony on these issues. (400) |
Public schools |
|
All members and ministers
will favor the use of the Bible in schools. (391) |
The |
Public
School Activities. The Wesleyan Church protests the
inclusion of such questionable items as social dancing in the public school
curriculum and maintains the right of its members to seek exemption from
participation by their children in all matters that are contrary to
scriptural doctrines and principles as expressed in the Articles of Religion,
Covenant Membership Commitments or Elementary Principles of The Wesleyan
Church, without prejudice to academic standing. (410.9) …The |
Military chaplains |
|
Chaplains should not be
abolished (392) |
|
|
Sunday |
|
Sunday sales should cease.
(393) |
TWC opposes legalization of merchandising on the Lord’s
Day. (187:6) |
Merchandising
on the Lord’s Day. The |
Christian nation |
|
“It is the bounded duty of
all members to work to secure an amendment to National and state
constitutions so that the name of Jesus Christ, the Son of God shall be
inserted in the State and National constitutions.” (394) |
TWC advocates Congressional laws providing for the free
exercise of religion in national life allowing for reference to God in
government life. (187:7) |
Religion
in Public Life. The Wesleyan Church, believing
that it is possible to allow recognition of God and the invoking of His aid
in public functions without violating the Constitution of the United States,
advocates the enactment of suitable legislation by the Congress which will
strengthen the present provision for the free exercise of religion in
national life and allow reference to, or the invoking of the aid of God, in
any governmental or public document, proceeding, activity, ceremony or
institution. (410.8) |
Peace, war & the draft |
“Inasmuch as many of our
people believe that military warfare is contrary to the teaching of the new
testament…while others” [believe it is an obligation] we lend our moral
support [to conscious objectors]. (76)
“We are opposed to compulsory peace-time military training.”(76.2) |
“Since war
results in so much suffering in the bodies, minds and souls of men, is
costly in the destruction of property, leaving heavy burdens upon succeeding
generations, producing much of the baser passions of life, we urge men and
nations seek by every legitimate means to avoid armed conflict.” A citizen’s
first duty is to God. (396) |
“Since war
results in so much suffering in the bodies, minds and souls of men, is
costly in the destruction of property, leaving heavy burdens upon succeeding
generations, producing much of the baser passions of life, we urge men and
nations seek by every legitimate means to avoid armed conflict.” Urges prayer for those in authority and for the quick return of
the Prince of Peace. (187:2) Recognizes responsibility of a person to enter
military service of their country but will support any among us who is a
sincere conscientious objector and asks to serve his country as a
non-combatant. (187:3) |
Peace. The Wesleyan Church, knowing that
war results in great suffering for the bodies, minds and souls of men and
women, staggering economic loss with its legacy of debt for future
generations, and the unleashing of the baser passions of life, urges that
persons and nations seek by every legitimate means to avoid armed conflict
among the peoples and nations of the world. The Wesleyan Church also urges that holy people
everywhere pray earnestly for those in authority, so that peace may prevail
(1 Tim. 2:2), and for the quick return of the Prince of Peace. (410.2) Military
Service. The |
Equal rights |
|
|
Upholds
the right of individuals to equal opportunity politically, economically and
religiously pledging itself to bring about dignity and happiness of all men
everywhere. (187:1) |
Equal Rights.
The Wesleyan Church upholds the
right of all individuals to equal opportunity politically, economically and
religiously, and pledges itself to an active effort to bring about the
possession of dignity and happiness by all people everywhere (cf. 220;
265:10, 11; 360:3d). (410.1) |
Prohibition |
|
|
The |
|
Moral purity |
|
|
We abhor ignoring God’s
laws of chastity and purity and vigorously oppose public acceptance of sexual
promiscuity and everything that promotes it. (187:5) |
Human
Sexuality. The |
Tongues |
|
|
Only a language readily
understood by the congregation is to be used in
worship; teaching that speaking on tongues is the proof of the Baptism of the
Holy Spirit in contrary to the Bible and the church. (190) |
|
Healing |
|
|
God is able to heal and
prayer for healing shall be encouraged (191) |
430.
Healing. The truth that Jesus is both able and willing to
heal the body as well as the human soul, whenever such healing is for His
glory, is clearly set forth in God’s Word and attested by the experience of
many of His people at the present day. Prayer for healing according to the
pattern set forth in the Scriptures shall be encouraged. |
Christian liberty |
|
|
God has given us liberty
but liberty should not be construed as license; we
realize there are differences of opinion and we should seek to avoid
offending the brother and avoid being a stumbling bock to weaker brothers.
(192) |
440. Christian
Liberty. Christ, through His death
on the cross, has freed His followers from sin and from bondage to the law.
Christians are “called unto liberty” (Gal. |
Christian unity |
|
|
TWC is cooperative and seeks unity and fellowship with
other Christians but does not believe there should be one all-inclusive
ecclesiastical organization. (193) |
450. Christian Unity. The |
Giving |
|
|
All we
have is owned by God and we
believe storehouse tithing is Scriptural and a member should tithe into the
church where they belong—The Wesleyan church is the storehouse for a tenth
but we urge members to contribute free will offerings beyond the tithe.
(195-196) |
460.
Meaning of Stewardship. The Scriptures teach that God is the owner of all
persons and all things, that people are His stewards of both life and
possessions, that God’s ownership and one’s stewardship ought to be acknowledged, and that every person shall be held
personally accountable to God for the exercise of their stewardship (cf.
265:3). God, as a God of system and order in all of His ways, has established
a system of giving which acknowledges His ownership and humankind’s
stewardship. To this end all His children should
faithfully tithe and present offerings for the support of the gospel. 465.
Storehouse Tithing. Storehouse tithing is a scriptural and practical
performance of faithfully and regularly placing the
tithe into that church to which the member belongs. Therefore, the financing
of the church shall be based on the plan of storehouse tithing, and The
Wesleyan Church shall be regarded by all its people
as the storehouse. All who are a part of The Wesleyan Church are urged to contribute faithfully one-tenth of all their
increase as a minimum financial obligation to the Lord and freewill offerings
in addition as God has prospered them. |
Fund raising |
|
|
The church shall be supported by tithing and no other method that
detracts form the Gospel message. (197) |
470.
Methods of Fund Raising. In the light of the scriptural
teaching concerning the giving of tithes and offerings (cf. 465) for the
support of the gospel, and for the erection of church buildings, no Wesleyan
church should engage in any method of fund raising which would detract from
these principles, hinder the gospel message, sully the name of the Church,
discriminate against the poor, or misdirect the people’s energies from
promoting the gospel. |
Wills & bequests |
|
|
Members should prepare an will remembering The Wesleyan church. (198) |
475.
Wills, Bequests and Annuities. It is essential in the exercise of Christian
stewardship that careful thought be given as to what
shall be done with one’s estate after death. Civil laws often do not provide
for the distribution of an estate in such a way as to glorify God. Each
Christian should give careful attention to the preparation of a last will and
testament in a careful and legal manner, and The Wesleyan Church and its
various ministries through the local church, the district, world missions,
extension and evangelism, education and benevolences are
recommended for consideration. The General Director of Stewardship
Ministries is prepared to assist in these matters (2070-2075; 4240; 4940). |
Substance abuse |
|
|
|
Substance
Abuse. The |
Divorce & remarriage |
|
|
|
Divorce
and Remarriage. On the basis of a careful study of the Scriptures,
and in keeping with its Covenant Membership Commitments (265:5), The Wesleyan
Church teaches the following with reference to divorce and remarriage after
divorce: (a) To obtain a divorce on other than scriptural grounds is a sin
against God and humanity. Such putting asunder of what God has joined is a
direct and deliberate act of disobedience against both the Law and the
Gospel. It separates one from God and subjects a member to Church discipline
(5115; 5120). (b) However, recognizing the fallen state of humanity, divorce has been recognized in the Scriptures as a valid and
permanent dissolution of marriage with all its rights and responsibilities.
Divorce is not reversible. There is no way to “restore” a dissolved marriage.
The divorced (unmarried) status can be changed only
by a new marriage to the same person or another person. No divorced and
remarried person has two spouses, only a former spouse and a present spouse,
as in Deuteronomy 24:1-4 and 1 Corinthians 7. (c) Divorce, however sinful the act and however serious the
consequences, is not “unpardonable.” A redeemed
sinner or reclaimed backslider is “free” to marry “in the Lord” or to remain
unmarried, a eunuch for the (d) The right to remarry in no way excuses the sin of divorce. It
only implies that the Church must forgive and restore those whom the Lord
forgives and restores. Neither penance nor penalty remain to the truly
penitent and restored sinner, or backslider, whatever the traumatic
consequences of the sin may be. (410.6) |
Judicial oaths |
|
|
|
Judicial
Oaths. The |
Abortion |
|
|
|
Abortion. The |
Amusements |
|
|
|
Use
of Leisure Time. The |
Dress |
|
|
|
Modesty
in Attire. The |
|
|
|
|
|
So, what do you think?
Click here to comment or read
comments for the first few weeks after this posting
Other columns on Membership Matters.
~ Abortion, alcohol & Wesleyans
~ Church Membership in early church
~ The
church’s right to require thing? ...
~ Minimum Membership Requirements
~ Lowering Church Membership Standards
~ Augustine’s Process for New Members
~ Membership Standards in the Didache
~ Membership rules from Bible?
~ The church & Binding & loosing
...
~ So how do YOU do Binding/loosing Drury
~ Who says what the Bible says?
~ membership
requirements not in Scripture?.
~ Membership minimums & Ideals:
~ Summary of “rules” of Wesleyan Church
~ SinAlert device –social drinkers
~ Membership
PowerPoiint
(
~ I’m a Tee Totaler
For reference: 2004
Discipline